Even though there was no concrete evidence linking Alex Murdaugh, a South Carolina attorney, to the murders of his wife and son, the jury found him guilty in less than three hours, primarily due to the defendant. “Only a handful of crucial pieces of evidence remained. According to Jessica Roth, a professor at Cardozo School of Law who followed the trial, there were three:
The cellphone video revealed the defendant’s presence at the crime scene, his denial to law enforcement agents that he had been at the kennels that night with his wife and son, and his testimony on the stand. Roth continued, the jury’s swift verdict suggests that, despite weeks of hearings, dozens of witnesses, and thousands of pieces of evidence, they did not view the case as complex.
Murdaugh insisted on his innocence and assured the judge he would never harm his 22-year-old son or 52-year-old wife prior to receiving a life sentence without the possibility of parole for their shooting deaths on Friday. Attorneys for the defence have vowed to file an appeal because they believe the judge tainted the case by admitting evidence of additional crimes for which Murdaugh was charged but not found guilty.
Murdaugh did himself no favours by taking the witness stand, where he admitted robbing clients of their money and lying to police about being at the kennels with his wife Maggie and son Paul just prior to their murders, according to observers. After his testimony, he was subjected to rigorous questioning by the prosecution.
Buster Murdaugh Health Update: Is He Sick? Wife And Family
Murdaugh claimed he was napping when asked why he didn’t take the dogs to the kennels before leaving the house to visit his ailing mother. Several witnesses, however, asserted that they heard his voice as well as those of his wife and children on cellphone footage taken at the kennels approximately five minutes prior to the gunshots.
Duncan Levin, a defence attorney and former New York prosecutor, compared the man’s situation to “stepping through a field of land mines” because he had to admit to lying about his location the night of the murder and stealing all of his customers’ money. I don’t believe juries react well to being lied to face-to-face.
Murdaugh’s claim that he initially lied because he didn’t trust law enforcement was refuted by evidence demonstrating his long-standing friendship with police and the fact that he was wearing a badge issued to law enforcement by his father, who had previously served as an elected solicitor.
According to Roth, the defendant had numerous ties to law enforcement and attempted to profit from them. According to my assessment, the jury did not believe his claim that he did not trust law enforcement. Friday, South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson stated that Murdaugh’s decision to testify ultimately proved “fatal” for him.
What happened to Gloria Satterfield, the Murdaugh family maid?
Wilson stated on NBC’s “Today Show” that Alex Murdaugh was the most compelling piece of evidence. The author states, “In my opinion, he believed he could argue his way out of this, and I believe that was the final straw for him.” According to juror Craig Moyer, the jury decided he should be found guilty after approximately 45 minutes of deliberation.
He admitted on ABC’s “Good Morning America” that the video showing Murdaugh’s voice at the crime scene just prior to the murders convinced him that Murdaugh was guilty. According to Moyer, Murdaugh’s testimony was false, and he never displayed genuine emotions when testifying. “I did not observe any genuine regret. I observed no sympathy. Friday, Dick Harpootlian, Murdaugh’s defence attorney, told reporters that calling Murdaugh to testify was not a mistake.
According to Harpootlian, the prosecution “made Murdaugh out to be a monster” with evidence of his financial misdeeds, so there was “no choice” but to call him as a witness. Harpootlian stated that the man would be “toasted” if he left without taking a stand. “If he took the stand, could he accomplish it? It seems unlikely that he did.
